A contributing building to the Helena Historic District, First Unitarian is nearly the newest
contributing ecclesiastical building in the district, but misses that mark by thirty years. Designed in the Richardsonian Romanesque style by C.S. Haire of the renowned architectural firm of
Link & Haire, the church was intended from the start to be used not only as a church, but a theatre, as well. Notably, it is the "
only known example of prominent architect C. S. Haire's work in the Richardsonian Romanesque style".
Six years before the writers of the American Guide Series book,
Montana, A State Guide Book, arrived in Helena the First Unitarian Church had been donated to the City of Helena to serve as its public library, and as such was the building they wrote about in the guide.
3. HELENA PUBLIC LIBRARY (open 9-9 weekdays; reference room only, 2-6 Sunday and holidays), Park Avenue and Lawrence Street, is housed in a small stone building of Tudor design, originally a church, but given to the city in 1933 by the Unitarian congregation, which also gave a fund of $20,000 for remodeling the building. The structure has some excellent woodwork, especially in the exposed walnut trusses that support the roof. The library has about 60,000 books and many newspapers and magazines. The founding association was formed in 1866.
From Montana, a state guide book, Page 165
1933 interrupted the plans of many in Helena with a serious earthquake that severely damaged, among other things, the city's library, so First Unitarian Church was donated to the city to be used as an interim library. Built with a sloping theatre floor and a proscenium stage, renovations made it useable as a library. It seems to have served in that capacity for quite some time. In 1976 the building was taken over by
Broadwater Productions, AKA Grand Street Theatre, which once again renovated the building, uncovering the sloping floor and recreating the original stage.
Over forty years later the building remains in use as the Grandstreet Theatre, staging live performance theatre through the year.
About Grandstreet Theatre
The building we now call the Grandstreet Theatre has sheltered Helena residents for over one hundred years –first as a house-of-worship, later as an interim city library following Helena’s destructive earthquakes, and since 1976, as the home of Montana’s oldest continuous community theater.
Built as a Unitarian Church in 1901, the facility included the sloping floor and the proscenium stage area as you see them today. Even then, early church documents indicated it was intended as a multi-use facility. The Reverend Leslie Willis Sprague was quoted in the Montana Sunday Record in October, 1901:
“It is not our purpose to so consecrate this building that it cannot be used for all sorts of conventions, meetings, entertainments, and in fact, for anything that tends to build up the better life … and we expect to have social rooms which will be in demand for various sorts of gatherings for clubs, classes, social events and all the rest….”
In 1933, the church was donated to the City of Helena in memory of Ellen Dean for use as an interim library following the near destruction of the original facility by earthquakes. Renovations were made to the building by leveling the house floor and adding a mezzanine.
In 1976, Broadwater Productions, known as Grand Street Theatre, assumed occupancy and transformed the building into Helena’s full-time, year-round community theater.
From the Grandstreet Theatre
FIRST UNITARIAN CHURCH
Outstanding architecture and a long history of community service make this stunning landmark much beloved. It is the only known example of prominent architect C. S. Haire's work in the Richardsonian Romanesque style. Magnificent round arches, a stylistic hallmark, are its most prominent feature. Public-spirited Unitarians believed that churches should serve the community. They planned the building to function as a public auditorium and theater as well as a church. At its dedication in 1901, Reverend Leslie Sprague said, "I do not believe God wants churches that are too holy for usefulness in any cause, even for the entertainment and pastime of His children." In 1933, the Unitarians donated the church to the city and it became the public library. It has been home to Grandstreet Theatre since 1976. The interior features a Tiffany window, exquisite woodwork, and the handsome original proscenium arch. In 2005, the 1901 blueprints inspired the replacement of the aging utilitarian window above the entry. The new window follows the designer's original sketch. Today Grandstreet Theatre, vital to the town's creative spirit, perpetuates the Unitarians' bequest.
From the NRHP plaque at the building