U.S.S. SEAWOLF
(SS-197)
3 OCTOBER 1944
ALL HANDS LOST
NORTH OF MOROTAI
BETWEEN
P.I. AND INDONESIA
On Eternal Patrol - The Loss of USS Seawolf (SS-197).
Seawolf (SS-197)
Compiled by Paul W. Wittmer and Charles R. Hinman, originally from:
U.S. Submarine Losses World War II, NAVPERS 15,784, 1949 ISSUE
SEAWOLF (LCDR A. L. Bontier) left Brisbane on 21 September 1944 beginning her 15th patrol, and arrived at Manus on 29 September. Leaving Manus on the same day, SEAWOLF was directed to carry certain stores and Army personnel to the east coast of Samar.
On 3 October SEAWOLF and NARWHAL exchanged SJ radar recognition signals at 0756. Later the same day an enemy submarine attack was made at 2° 32'N, 129° 18'E, which resulted in the sinking of U.S.S. SHELTON (DE-407). Since there were four friendly submarines in the vicinity of this attack, they were directed to give their positions and the other three did, but SEAWOLF was not heard from. On 4 October, SEAWOLF again was directed to report her position, and again she failed to.
U.S.S. ROWELL (DE-403) and an aircraft attacked a submarine in the vicinity of the attack on SHELTON, having at that time no knowledge of any friendly submarines in the area, and it was thought that SEAWOLF must be held down by these anti-submarine activities. It is possible that SEAWOLF was the submarine attacked.
The report from ROWELL indicates that an apparently lethal attack was conducted in conjunction with a plane, which marked the spot with dye. ROWELL established sound contact on the submarine, which then sent long dashes and dots (Editor's note: Rowell's War Diary characterizes the signal as "a continuous dash") which ROWELL stated bore no resemblance to the existing recognition signals. After one of the several hedgehog attacks a small amount of debris and a large air bubble were seen. It has been established that the Japanese submarine RO-41 sank SHELTON on 3 October, and was able to return to Japan.
In view of the above facts, and the fact that there is no attack listed in the Japanese report of anti-submarine attacks which could account for the loss of SEAWOLF, it is possible that SEAWOLF was sunk by friendly forces in an anti-submarine attack on 3 October 1944, in the vicinity of 02° 32'N, 129° 18'E. It is also possible that she was lost due to an operational casualty or as a result of an unrecorded enemy attack.
During her first fourteen patrols, SEAWOLF sank 27 enemy ships, and damaged 13. This gave her total tonnage for ships sunk and damaged of 108,600 and 69,600, respectively. On the day the war began she started patrolling in the vicinity of northern Luzon, but returned with no damage to her credit. Her second patrol was the passage from Manila to Port Darwin and SEAWOLF did not meet any enemy ships. On her third patrol SEAWOLF transported a cargo of .50 caliber anti-aircraft ammunition to Corregidor in January 1942 and then took passengers from there to Surabaya. Patrolling the vicinity of Lombok Straits for her fourth run, SEAWOLF sank a transport and damaged three light cruisers, two transports and a freighter. She received the Navy Unit Commendation for this patrol. Returning to the Philippine area for her fifth patrol, SEAWOLF sank a freighter. In the Makassar Strait for her sixth patrol, SEAWOLF sank a tanker and a freighter-transport, while she damaged another tanker.
On her seventh patrol, SEAWOLF made the passage from Fremantle to Pearl Harbor, patrolling at Davao Gulf, Palau and Yap enroute. She sank the Japanese freighter-transport SAGAMI-MARU 40 miles inside the mouth of Davao Gulf on 3 November 1942. In addition, SEAWOLF sank two other freighter-transports and damaged a freighter on this patrol. On her eighth patrol, in the Bonins-Formosa Area, SEAWOLF sank a large freighter, a tanker, two sampans, and, on 23 April 1943, Patrol Boat number 39, a converted Japanese destroyer. Going to an area off the China coast north of Formosa for her ninth patrol, SEAWOLF sank a freighter-transport and a sampan, and damaged a destroyer escort. SEAWOLF's tenth patrol was in the East China Sea in August and September 1943; here she sank three large freighters and two sampans, while she damaged a third sampan. She conducted her eleventh patrol in the South China Sea and sank a large freighter-transport and an unidentified ship, and damaged a freighter. In the East China Sea north of Formosa SEAWOLF sank a freighter-transport, three freighters and damaged three more freighters on her twelfth war patrol. SEAWOLF's mission on her thirteenth patrol was a photographic reconnaissance of Palau. She also rescued two downed aviators during a U.S. carrier air raid there. On her fourteenth patrol, SEAWOLF delivered cargo to guerrilla activities in the Philippines.
Seventeen U.S. Army personnel who were being transported by Seawolf were also lost, and are included on this list. Please note that some sources fail to list Tomas Rosete, who was lost with his shipmates when Seawolf was sunk in October, 1944.
The following men were lost while serving on USS Seawolf (SS-197).
Emiliano A. Almero (Army)
Marion Lee Asa
John Michael Astarita
Lloyd Richard Balch
Francis Arden Ballard
Jack Bannister
Arnold Frank Bargenquast
William Berndt Beck
Gerald Edgar Bekke
Robert Jordan Bennett
Patrick Kenneth Bergevin
Dallas Victor Bolon
Albert Marion Bontier
George Batara Bueno (Army)
James Burdell Call
James Purcell Carithers
Robert Jack Carnegie
Wilfred Leslie Cash
Amadeo C. Cendania (Army)
Edward Chapman
Norman D. Coon
Chester Mayo Copas
Wayne Houston Cotton
Robert Leon Cox
James Patrick Cunnally
Robert Floyd Devitt
Paul Doane
John Lewis Ewing
Robert Nelson Fixler
Kenneth Judd Flynn
Alberto C. Francisco (Army)
Peter Franco
Lloyd George
James Grimes
William Thomas Hadley
Charles H. Hammill (Army)
John Gordon Harris
Robert P. Herbig (Army)
Alfred Herman Howard
Roy Edward Huff
Artemio Irujo Ibea (Army)
James Everard Johnson
Michael Jurinic
Jack Edward Kenney
Howell Stewart Kopp (Army)
Charles Stanley Krempa
Alfred Eric Kuehn
Chester Gelean Lawson
Merton Hibbard Leeman, Jr.
Gilbert Roland Likert
Carl Dean Lynch
Dallas Leroy Malone
George Franklin Marston, Jr.
Charles Robert Maus
Walter Glen "Bud" McCoy
Forrest Samuel Michael
George Francis Miller (Army)
Ralph Van Dorn Miller
Richard Lawrence Miller
Robert Thomas Miller
Lannie Tolbert Mills, Jr.
Harold Edward Mitchell
Edward Lyle Morris
Joseph Albert Morris
George Gilbert Nazay
Donald Joseph Naze
George Melvin Needham
Clinton Leroy Nivison
Edward Francis O'Brien, Jr.
Albert Francis Page
Leonard Alton Page
George E. Peralta (Army)
Elmer Norman Peterson
Wasil Politylo
Emil L. Pugosa (Army)
Aquilino B. Ramos (Army)
William Frederick Reiland, Jr.
Guy Benjamin Rhoads
Mahlon Richard Riggle
Juan Flores Rimando (Army)
Saturnino Rocaya
Ireneo R. Rodriguez (Army)
Benjamin Franklin Rogers
Tomas Rosete
Ruperto R. Ruiz (Army)
John Colby Sadler
James William Saint
Gerald Andrew Steinecker
Clarence Elias Strausser
Edward John Szendrey
Antonino B. Tria (Army)
William Hopkins Underhill
John Van Andel
Vernon Palmer Wall
Thomas Wilson Warren
Michael Paul Wiegenstein
Braynard L. Wise (Army)
David Bernard Wyatt
Robert Porterfield Young
Edward Andrew Zuel