Located on the corner of Water Street, Beck’s Cove and George Street in the Water Street National Historic District, in some ways you might say that the Yellow Belly Corner building serves to anchor the Water Street National Historic District. This commercial building was one of the few to survive the "Great St. John’s Fire of 1892". Today it is home to the Yellow Belly Brewer and Public House. The brewer's website claims that the building was constructed in 1725, making it one of the oldest structures in North America. It also proclaims the location to be the very spot "where the 'Great Fire of 1892' was finally extinguished". However, the Heritage Foundation of Newfoundland & Labrador considers the building to be "a fine representation of mercantile buildings constructed after the fire of 1846", strongly suggesting the building is much younger that what is claimed above.
Yellow Belly Corner was designated as a provincial Registered Heritage Structure in 2006. The following description of the building and its significance is taken from the Heritage Foundation of
Newfoundland & Labrador website:
Heritage Value
Yellow Belly Corner was designated as a Registered Heritage Structure by the Heritage Foundation of Newfoundland and Labrador in 2006 because of its historical, aesthetic and cultural values. The building is significant because it is a fine representation of mercantile buildings constructed after the fire of 1846. It is one of a small number of such buildings that survived the Great St. John’s Fire of 1892. This building is historically important for its long historical association with commercial activities in St. John’s. It was originally constructed as commercial premises on the first floor, with the upper floors serving as private dwellings. Aesthetically Yellow Belly Corner reflects nineteenth century British commercial vernacular design, with typical 3 1/2 storeys, medium pitch side gable roof, and rectangular window openings. The weathered stone masonry and brick facade give an impression of solidity while its human scale is inviting. Yellow Belly Corner has great commercial and cultural value to the community and to Newfoundland and Labrador, as it is associated with the commercial development of the province, and as it was well known as a meeting place for various nineteenth century Irish county factions. According to popular local folklore and oral history, the name “Yellow Belly Corner” was given after the colour of sashes worn by the “Yellowbellies” from County Wexford. The Yellowbellies were one of the various Irish factions, including the “Wheybellies” from County Waterford, the “Clear-Airs” from County Tipperary, the “Doones” from County Kilkenny, and the “Dadyeens” from County Cork, who would meet and fight on this site, Newfoundland’s contemporary equivalent of the Gangs of New York. Yellow Belly Corner is the cornerstone of the Water Street National Historic District. This district is of great national significance as no other mid-19th century ranges of commercial buildings in the provincial capitals or major urban centres are known to exist. Source: Heritage Foundation of Newfoundland and Labrador property file “St. John’s – Yellow Belly Corner – FPT 2713?
Character Defining Elements
All elements that define the building’s mid nineteenth-century commercial design including: – coursed rubble masonry and red brick voussoirs and window surrounds on the Beck’s Cove gable end; – classically inspired doorway framed with a stone pediment and pilasters on the Beck’s Cove gable end; – location of a slight Scotch gable on the Beck’s Cove gable end; – red brick facade, sandstone lintels and sandstone window sills on the Water Street facade; – original uniform window openings throughout; – the line of the original mid pitch gable roof, with end brick and masonry chimneys; – original location, dimensions, and height of the building; – Water Street side traditional, large-windowed storefront, utilizing traditional materials and detailing; and, – use of traditional building materials throughout the building.
Source: heritagefoundation.ca/heritage-property/yellow-belly-corner-registered-heritage-structure/, accessed March 2019