Pithole City - Cornplanter Township, Pennsylvania - Ghost Towns on Waymarking.com

The coordinates above are for the Pithole City Historic Museum. There visitors can hike down the hill to experience the remains of this once vibrant city.

According to the NRHP Record Archive - Pithole City, when plotted in May of 1865, had five-hundred building lots and twenty-two streets. The major streets of the city were Holmden, running north and south, and First, which ran east and west and intersected Holmden. As the population increased to over 10,000, many wooden structures were quickly built to accommodate the influx. Nearly all the structures were quickly build to accommodate the influx. Nearly all the structures were of wood which proved a hazard when a series of fires broke out later in the year.

At its height there were two banks, two telegraph offices, a daily paper, a water works, fire company, two churches, many boarding houses, grocery stores, hardware stores, machine shops, saloons, and brothels.

Today Pithole City is a series of streets, cellar holes, and guide markers describing the features of the former community. It is located on a slope above the Pithole Creek, north of Plumer and about tem miles southeast of Titusville.

According to Wikipedia - In January 1865, oil was discovered at the Frazier Well (also called the US Well) along Pithole Creek at 250 barrels a day, six years after Edwin L. Drake struck oil at Drake Well in Titusville, PA and six weeks after the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln. Two weeks later, oil was discovered at the nearby Twin Wells. By April, 3,000 Teamsters were employed at Pithole.

In May 1865, Colonel A.P. Duncan and George C. Prather purchased the land around Pithole from the widow of Thomas Holmden for $25,000. They divided the land into 500 lots, which they leased to businesses and individuals coming to work in the thriving oil industry. With the discovery of another oil well in June, the Homestead Well, population in Pithole quickly rose to around 2,000 people. Oil was discovered at Grant Well and Pool Well in August, and by September, Pithole was home to 15,000 people, had 57 hotels, The Pithole Daily Record newspaper, and the third busiest post office in Pennsylvania, handling more than 5,000 pieces of mail a day. By October, oil production around Pithole was estimated at 6,000 barrels a day. The borough was incorporated in December 1865. The Pithole Valley Railroad was completed, a reservoir and water pipe system was laid out, and two hotels Danforth House and the Bonta House opened. In early 1866, the town still welcomed prizefighter Ben Hogan to the Athenaeum theather (February), dedicated a Methodist church (May), and organized the men's social club, the Swordsman Club (June), but the town was already declining. From its peak population of 15,000 people in September 1865, population had already fallen to 4,000 by January 1866.

Oil was running out, the hastily constructed wooden buildings were falling victim to fire, and new wells were being discovered at nearby areas. Major fires in April and August of 1866 burning several city blocks and 27 wells brought the population down even further to just 2,000 people by December 1866. After another fire destroyed 20 buildings in 1868, the newspaper was relocated to Petroleum Center, PA and by 1870, the population had fallen to 281. In 1877, Pithole's charter as a borough was officially annulled. The city was sold to Venango County commissioners for $4.37 in 1879.

In 1961, the site was given to the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission by owner James Stevenson. Today, only a few cellars and mowed paths mark the buildings and former streets of Pithole. A visitor's center, with a small museum, city directories, and a scale model of Pithole at its peak, is open from June through Labor Day. The site is maintained by the Drake Well Museum.

Reason for Abandonment: Economic Date Abandoned: 01/01/1870 Related Web Page: [Web Link]

Visit Instructions:
Please include a unique picture or two with your log if possible.

Recent Visits/Logs:

Date Logged Log User Rating   08/23/2019 TyroneShoelaces visited it 07/06/2016 2-2 wheelers visited it 06/13/2015 jhorter visited it 07/13/2013 vhasler visited it 10/25/2012 lan46 visited it 10/25/2012 rainbowtree visited it 06/09/2012 sql_geek visited it 10/15/2011 lknox visited it 09/26/2011 bpratt visited it 09/17/2011 Facedances visited it 07/01/2011 uccacher visited it 09/19/2010 Tprints visited it 07/12/2009 Sparticus06 visited it 05/23/2009 Dory The Explorer visited it 09/06/2008 lp5324 visited it

View all visits/logs